Ashley Holstrom


The Joys of Rereading

Plus, an announcement!

Crooked Reads is a monthly newsletter offering bite-sized reviews of three books fitting to a theme—like weird science or sports romance or realistic financial advice—and sometimes other things, like today’s missive, from a professional book person.

The newsletter will always be free, and the best way to support me and my work is by becoming a paid subscriber. But if that isn’t your jam, you can always buy me a book from my wishlist.


Oh, hi.

Since quitting some of my writing gigs earlier this year, I realized a lot of brain space has opened up for me to write the things I want to write. I’m journaling again and considering doing more in this space: Little essays about being bookish, personal bits about being alive, and maybe—get ready—things I learn while writing my book.

That’s right. I’m finally doing it: Writing a memoir of my life with scoliosis, blended with history, science, medicine, and whatever else I stumble upon in my research. It’s currently a single document titled “Word Vomit,” followed by another endless document (and a variety of notes on my phone) filled with articles to read, books to check out, memories to mine, and a slew of potential topics to peruse.

One of the first steps I’m taking is to read every scoliosis book I can find, starting with the rereads: Deenie and Braced. I didn’t read these books until I was older than the intended audience, but they’re so powerful in bringing me back to feeling like a 13-year-old again.

Rereading was once my main form of reading. Why delve into new books when you could return to the books you already know you love? But then I saw that TBR calculator (which doesn’t seem to exist anymore) that took the number of books on your TBR, how many books you read last year, and your age, and spit out some horrifying “you’ll finish all your books in the year 3032!” statement.

So I quit that rereading nonsense.

I had a wee bit of an existential crisis this spring and my solace was burrowing into myself and the things that brought me comfort when I was a teen. I reread the Twilight books, rewatched all the movies—and bonus content, which come in the deluxe 10-disc box set that Anthony got me for Christmas last year—and started to feel a little better.

Needing more fantasy, I devoured the A Court of Thorns and Roses series—and promptly reread them all on audiobook. I’m planning on rereading Fourth Wing before Iron Flame comes out in November. I’m revisiting more books I loved in some of my darker days so I can read them and feel cozy again.

There’s a sort of magic to rereading that I never considered before. You get to revisit a place with hindsight and deepen your understanding of the world within the pages. If you annotate your books, maybe you find joy or surprise in the passages that resonated with your younger self. Maybe you’re reminded of the person you were the last time you read the book.

For me, it’s fun because my memory is absolute garbage. I forget all plot points as soon as I finish a book; all that remains is how it made me feel. So, in a way, rereading is kind of like reading a book for the first time again.

So far, my rereading has remained in the world of fiction. As I begin the (very) early stages of writing a book, I’m dipping my toes into some of the classic writing guides I read a decade ago, and I can’t wait to see what old ideas become new for me in this new phase.

What about you? Are you a rereader?

The nightstand

In the Dream House is a masterpiece. It’s a memoir about queer domestic abuse and writing and how to exist in the world. The format here is perfect, with most chapters just a page long and focusing on a single moment in time. Tales of the past are told in second person, putting you right in the middle of the horrifying story. It’s just magnificent—and a book I see myself returning to again and again.

Note: This book is on sale for Latinx & Hispanic Heritage Month at Bookshop! Use code HHM2023 to get 20% this and other fabulous nonfiction titles.

xoxo


Head’s up! I’m an affiliate with Bookshop.org and may earn a commission if you click through any book links and make a purchase.

⚡️ Archive | ContactInstagram | Goodreads | Tumblr | Wishlist

36 responses to “The Joys of Rereading”

  1. I am so torn between re-reading and keeping up with my ever-expanding TBR (especially now I also work in a bookshop) but this year I’ve re-read a handful of books and I think I’m kind of finding a balance. I’ve now got a shelf dedicated to stuff I want to re-read for various reasons – as you say to remember things or to revisit it with fresh perspectives, or simply because I read it 9 years ago and can’t remember why I loved it so much. So hard when there’s so much good stuff we’ll never read but I guess that’s just the complexity of being a reader!

    Like

    1. Amen to all of that. Shelving the to-re-read books in their own spot is such a good idea!

      Like

      1. I think it’s really helped!

        Like

  2. I was a re-reader as a teenager and haven’t done it since then — largely because there are sooo many new books I want to read — but recently, I’ve been playing around with the idea of re-reading the same book every year for exactly the reasons you mentioned: benchmarking, using it as a tool to better understand myself, and of course, enjoying the comfort of familiar characters and plot.

    Like

    1. Oh, I love that! What book would be the one you read every year, if you did it?

      Like

  3. Belated congratulations on starting your memoir!!!

    Like

    1. Thank you!!

      Like

  4. I LOVE to reread but do feel like I’ve gotten away from it recently — because there are just SO many new books coming out, it’s hard to keep up. But like I recently reread Dicey’s Song for the thousandth time and it was just so good, and comforting, and really felt like home to me. I want to do more of it. Here for your memoir btw!

    Like

    1. YES, old cozy books DO feel like home! That’s how I feel about some of my fave teen books, where just the smell and feel of the paper of MY edition is the most reassuring thing. Thank you!!

      Like

  5. Sandra Ann Miller Avatar

    Congrats, Ashley! Can’t wait to read your memoir! Did you know Laurie Stone of @Everything Is Personal is doing a Zoom on Saturday about writing memoir? Check out her ‘stack and send her an email that you’re interested (if you are). It should be fun. Laurie is a hoot and a half. And I’ve given up on my TBR. It takes me forever to get through a book theses days. Some writer I am. LOL. xo

    Like

    1. Thank you so much! I’ll check that out.

      Like

  6. ASHLEY!!! V. excited about your book!!!

    Like

    1. THANK YOU, friend!!!

      Like

  7. Congratulations on starting the book-writing process! How thrilling. I’m rooting for you as you embark on this extremely meaningful project! 🥳

    Like

    1. Thank you, Maddie!!

      Like

  8. When I was younger I was a re-reader but then dedicating my education to English Lit meant that I just had to read a lot and so re-reading (or reading anything that wasn’t related to my course) felt pointless and like I was wasting time. And I felt that way up until some point last year when The Secret History started whispering to me that it wanted to be read again and then when that one started whispering, others books that I loved joined in and V.E Schwab announced she was returning to The Darker Shades of Magic world which meant that my attitude to re-reading started to shift and I am slowly returning to books that I loved. In fact this week I am starting my re-read of the original Darker Shades of Magic trilogy in prep for the first book of the new series being published next week and now that autumn has arrived The Secret History is going to get another run out. As well as Fourth Wing the moment I get that dispatch email about Iron Flame!

    Like

    1. I have a friend who rereads The Secret History every year! And I’ve yet to read it once. 🙈

      Like

  9. Every year I reach for books I’ve already read. They make up about a quarter at least if not more of the books I read each year and I’m not necessarily counting the ones I have on hand, by my desk all marked up with notes on structure, lines I loved and other things that help me with whatever I’m writing.

    I dip in and out of some — read a section at a time or a chapter but often, if I do that, I end up rereading the whole thing. I find something new each time which is kind of a thrill.

    I’m very happy for you . It is wonderful to know you are writing the book you want to write. I wish you all good things in the months ahead!

    Like

    1. That’s so lovely, Betsy. And thank you. 💕

      Like

  10. Amy - The Tonic Avatar

    So many great books to get to, so tragically little time. When I re-read, I feel guilty about the books that have been on my TBR shelf for years now.

    Like

    1. Relatable.

      Like

  11. I have had so many great conversations here with people about re-reading including some that led to a really interesting look at whether re-readers also order the same thing off of menus: https://createmefree.substack.com/p/if-you-re-read-books-do-you-also

    I love what you’ve said about seeing things differently when you read a book again. It reminds me of what Jodie of Hey, YA said recently about how we have all been young and have those young inner parts inside of ourselves so sometimes reading YA can heal those parts. (I’m paraphrasing.)

    Like

    1. I never thought to put those two things together. I absolutely order the same thing at restaurants, but am very intentional with my rereads. This is fascinating.

      Like

      1. I wouldn’t have thought of it either until it came up in the conversation and then I found it so interesting!

        Like

  12. Re-reader here 🙋‍♀️

    Like

  13. I almost never reread, because like you said there are so many books out there that I’ll never get to them all so I can’t get stuck rereading. But I’m also reconsidering this position. A bit. I’d love to reread some of my favorites from before I started this newsletter, like ‘The Left Hand of Darkness’ or ‘Ubik’ or ‘The Count of Monte Cristo.’ It would be interesting to come back to something after a long time to see if it still resonates. Thank you for inspiring this thought!

    Like

    1. That could be a great post in itself! I hope something good comes of it. :)

      Like

  14. I used to reread my favorite books and now never reread anything at all because of that damn TBR calculator, which scared the bejusus out of me when I first found it (and still does). I just always think, I don’t have time to read all the books I want to read before I die! And that pretty much stops my rereading in its tracks.

    Like

    1. Add in the bonkers number of new books coming out every month and it’s a recipe for disaster!

      Like

      1. Exactly.

        Like

  15. Delana Pennington Avatar

    I tend to reread my favorite scenes or chapters when I want a pick me up, or to feel the way I felt when I read it the first time.

    Like

    1. I can’t believe I never thought of just popping in for specific scenes. This is brilliant.

      Like

  16. Congratulations on starting your word vomit draft 🎉🎉

    I remember reading Deanie as a teenager. It was serialised in a weekly magazine that I read.

    Like

    1. Thank you! And that’s so cool!!

      Like

  17. Jennifer Silva Redmond Avatar
    Jennifer Silva Redmond

    I love re-reading books. I’ve reread many modern books many times, as well as everything Austen, Dickens, and George Eliot. Recently I read The Music Shop by Rachel Joyce and almost immediately (like a week later) I read it again. My though in starting the first few pages was “How did she do that?” and then I got caught up all over again! Brilliant.

    Like

    1. Ooh, I had that “how did she do that?” feeling after finishing Little Fires Everywhere by Celeste Ng. Definitely did NOT find out how she did it, lol.

      Like

Leave a reply to Elizabeth Marro Cancel reply